top of page
Writer's pictureThy Nguyen

Blog #2 - Constraints, Analysis, and Challenges


 

In the process of designing RC supply vent system, the beginning of our journey has already unveiled or encountered some challenges.

The main frame component’s dimensions of 6 inches by 10 inches constrain and limit the space available for the integration of adjustable vents, fans, and electrical components. This restriction permits manipulation primarily in terms of thickness for the incorporated elements. Efficiently arranging these elements within this confined space presents a significant challenge, especially when aiming for a seamless interior and exterior appearance. Keeping the device's weight under 5 lbs while ensuring structural stability can be challenging. The design must withstand potential or dampens vibrations from the fan and operational stresses.


The adjustable vents component is constrained by the requirement to achieve precision within 0.125 inches laterally or 20° angular increments, posing the challenge of ensuring precise positioning without impeding airflow. Ensuring the fan's consistency within these increments and preventing deviation from its initial position over time is essential through the implementation of a position-tracking system. Feedback components like encoders, potentiometers, PWM (Pulse Width Modulation), etc., offer ways to monitor position, but additional factors such as cost, precision, power requirements, and environmental conditions need careful consideration. Another critical consideration is to ensure that the fan provides sufficient airflow without causing pressure issues for the central AC system.


The fan component needs to operate at a noise level below 25 dB, comparable to that of a computer fan. Challenges arise when seeking an off-the-shelf fan that is both compatible with duct static pressure and capable of increasing the original CFM by 1.5. Additionally, at maximum fan speed, the components should not produce any rattling, presenting the challenge of creating a robust structure or implementing a dampening feature.


Meeting the minimum 12V power supply requirement for all components within the device may require careful power management and selection of suitable components. Developing the necessary coding for seamless communication between the microcontroller, fan, vent actuators, wireless control system, and temperature sensor is crucial. Ensuring reliability in wireless communication and feedback control is also a challenge.


In summary, the physical constraints outlined above pose several challenges in designing the RC supply vent system. Meeting precise positioning requirements, noise limitations, and power supply needs and ensuring efficient component integration are key design considerations. Additionally, managing weight and structural stability within the specified dimensions is essential.


 

After encountering the constraints, another time consuming process is the validation of design through technical analysis. Our latest project update delves into thermal dynamics shaping the future of temperature control. Combining the principles from heat transfer, thermodynamics, and fluid dynamics, our comprehensive analysis is required for the development of device.

 

Fluid Dynamics Analysis:

Objective: Understand the airflow behavior from the central AC to the outlet of the vents.

Analysis: Utilize fluid dynamics principles, including the Equation of Continuity or the Darcy-Weisbach Equation (Pressure Drop in Pipes), to determine pressure drop, velocity profile, and temperature changes at any point along the path.

Benefits: Aid in the selection of fan CFM capacity by providing crucial insights into airflow characteristics, ensuring optimal performance and efficiency of the ventilation system.

 

Heat Transfer and Thermodynamic Analysis:

Objective: Analyze temperature changes from the central unit to the desired room and evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed device in achieving precise temperature control.

Analysis: Calculate and model heat transfer principles in the system. Simulate temperature changes under different conditions using heat transfer analysis, including convection and radiation modes. Utilize the Ideal Gas Law, First Law of Thermodynamics, and Mass Flow Rate Equation.

Benefit: Determine the device's impact on achieving ±1°F temperature control. Identify any heat transfer issues to the proposed solution. These equations relate the mass flow rate of air to the heat transfer rate and the temperature change, which are instrumental in determining the airflow required to cool a room to the desired temperature.

 

Statics with Dynamics and Control of Mech Design Analysis: Objective: Evaluate the structural integrity and compatibility of the proposed device with existing vent systems. Ensure the proposed device can withstand the applied forces and not exceed acceptable material stress limits. Ensure damping and natural frequency help understand the device's response to vibrations from the fan.

Analysis: Evaluate stress distribution and potential weak points.

Benefits: Confirm that the device adheres to the size constraints (6 inches by 10 inches). Ensure the device can be mounted with just two screws. Identify any structural modifications needed for compatibility. Confirm that the operating frequency of the fan does not lead to resonance and increased vibrations.


 

Soft challenges associated with our project are inevitable. As temperature changes on more minor scales, it can be difficult for the human body to perceive. This is an issue because the purpose of our device is to minimize temperature gradients by adjusting airflow to experience a comfortable temperature. Human perception of temperature is necessary to validate our devices' success. The integration of fans and electrical components necessary to operate our device is expected to increase design bulkage. To make it compatible with pre-existing supply vent mount holes, our design needs to be sleep and kept at the minimal width possible. In an effort to make our design sleek, we must minimize wire exposure. This is done by organizing the wiring path and utilizing the smallest possible wiring. Another soft challenge is making our device operational and responsive to commands outlined in our coding.

Maintaining consistency in the design, from the physical vents to the vent controller, is crucial and should not be an afterthought. The user interface's importance is crucial, with a focus on the device's controllability. The design of a remote control interface must prioritize intuitiveness, making it easy for users to comprehend and operate. Thoughtful consideration should be given to integrating adjustable vents and fan control into the overall user interface, aiming for simplicity and ease of use for homeowners.





6 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page